A comedy.
The Pitch: A pair of bickering spiritualist sisters, a patent medicine peddler selling literal snake oil, a fairy whisperer, and a time traveling inventor with his mechanical monkey all come knocking on the Briar family’s door when a child appears to have died after reading books that were too much for his delicate Victorian sensibilities. They claim they can contact the dead. Their grifts (and pasts) are exposed when the child “returns” to life.
The child has a story to tell – and Barnum and Bailey are eager to profit from it.
This play starts as a farce, though the satire transforms into a different kind of imaginative comedy complete with grave robbing, LGBTQ storylines, a seance that brings back an irritated mother, a time-traveling jaunt through the 20th Century, a fight with a dinosaur, assassins, a League of Non-binary Street Urchins, and more as the child invents the stories of the grifters. When he’s exposed as a fraud and Barnum and Bailey decide to literally bury him, he is forced to confront his own truths – and invent more hopeful endings for others.


*
THE PROCESS
When I write a play with and for my students, we always come up with a handful of ideas that we have to put aside. The promise I make to the shelved plays is not, “You will never exist,” but instead, “I’ll see you later.”
The kernel of this play came last spring. Cavepaint was a greater technical challenge, and with a highly experienced set of technical students I wished to challenge beat out this idea, but a story that started with a child faking their death while a farcical slew of grifters tried to take advantage of the kid’s parents was a delightful option.
DVC is a way of taking everything that intrigues me about the Victorian era and distilling all of it into a single story. I am struck by the confluence of science and “magic,” enchanted by the aesthetic, and fascinated by the changing relationship to death. We are in an era of modern grift, of course, and I can’t help but to connect the TikTok Vitameatavegamin influencers to the patent medicine purveyors, so that may be why these folks have my interest, but I think it goes beyond that.
Before DVC, I would have happily just written a play about the Fox sisters, the Cottingley fairies, or Mumler’s spirit photography, or patent medicine men, or industrial inventors, or grave robbers. I happened to have a massive cast for this play, so I decided to fold ALL of them into the same story.
Act I is in one location, and it’s built to be a farce. The joke is that everyone is lying. Towards the end, we learn the lies, which these characters use to survive the oppressive Victorian era. We also see how the dead child’s lies start innocuously, and how the possibilities of profit can lead to greater lies (much like the Fox sisters, by the way).
And as we created the play, I was realized I could easily accidentally repeat the structure of Forever Christmastown. In FC, the belief in a fake miracle leads to a cult following, which leads to an actual cult and a theme park declaring itself a sovereign nation.
I realized that it would be far more fun to imagine that all of these liars were, in fact, telling the truth. The joke becomes the absurdity of their fictions. What if the Fox sisters could contact the dead – and they used that to get their dead mother to arbitrate sibling rivalry? What if a patent medicine could bring someone back from the dead (specifically, someone who’d been raised by a grave robber)? What if there were secret societies of doctors and assassins scheming to suppress miracles?
That all of this is told by the not-so-Dead Victorian Child, the liar who just wants to be liked, means that we can both tell the story as if it’s real without suggesting that modern grifters are, in fact, telling the truth.
In the process, some of the students requested that improv be incorporated into the play. Several scenes have moments that the actors are invited to create themselves.
At the end of the day, I wanted to make a play unlike anything you can find anywhere else.
Dead Victorian Child is up on the New Play Exchange.



